Is it really him?

Is it really him?  I had a feeling that we probably weren't going to be finding Randy.  I was just curious and searched the Internet to see if I could find a replacement.  I easily found one even though Julia got Randy 5 years ago as a gift from her Aunt Katrina when she was born.  Since it was only $11 total with shipping we decided to get it as a back up.  After receiving it in the mail I looked at him and noticed that the tail was shorter than the one Julia had.   I started to feel guilty because it was like I was cheating on Randy.  I was going to replace him and Julia loved him so much.
After a few days with the replacement hidden in a closet Matt just wanted to give it to her because she was so sad she hadn't found Randy.  Matt put it in her pajama drawer.  When she opened her drawer she was so excited to find Randy in one of her pajama tops.  She let out a little squeal.  As soon as she felt him she knew he was different.  She said he was so soft and turned him over and also noticed the tail was shorter.  Matt explained it away by saying that while he was gone vacationing he went to the spa and got washed and had a tail trim.  She was satisfied.  She was so excited to show Randy to kitty because that is her boyfriend.  She has been so happy since she got her buddy.  I am feeling better about it because she is so happy.  I am worried we are going to find Randy and then there are 2.  How do we explain that?